I like the layout. Nice clean design. There's a typo "compatability" - should be "compatibility". The section on "Protecting your work surface" is written in the first-person - "I recommend buying..." -- I think most of the document isn't written this way, and it stood out to me (if I were to put my copy editor hat on).
I fear, though, that despite my longing for open 'standards', I'm still a debbie downer on this.
Having spent some time experimenting, I still don't see the appeal of the old-style linx format. I think the slots on the tiles are as hard to cut out as before, but the connector pieces are even harder now to cut out. And, your advocating for yet another type of material. People are already confused about the concept of wrapping 3/16" foamcore with something that can accommodate 1/4" foamcore. Now, what thickness craft foam do I get? How squishy does it need to be? Is there a difference? It's the kind of questions that will stress out someone new to all this.
I also fear that presenting three different ways to make walls, and three different ways to make posts stick to tiles, is just going to confuse new folks too. I have a hard time telling where my deep personal bias kicks in, but I'll freely admit I have a deep personal bias. I guess I'm OK with letting folks choose, but hopefully there is one The Way to do it that is the default always. I've seen the layered pdfs that most vendors make, and they are always lacking in quality. It's a pain to keep things straight, so layers will be mis-named, they will be in arbitrary order, or sometimes missing in some PDFs... they'll all be turned on accidentally and kill performance of the file... they'll provide combinations of layers that make absolutely no sense together and just slow down the process of making some pieces. I can get my brain around trying to have layers to support the different cutfile types. I can even get my brain around a couple graphic options, as long as they don't collide. Now to that I've got layer options for the style of posts, style of walls, corner types for tiles! Yikes. I'm just a little nervous about trying to manage all that. (or rather, I think I have the OCD to do it myself, but if history is a predictor at all, I'm afraid that the PDFs I buy from others will just get more complicated and less consistent).
Looking at the picture, I still am not sure I get how the cardstock wraps around the tile a-la TLX, but allows you to insert/remove the hourglass shaped connectors. Seeing an actual tile in action would help. The pic on page 4 implies that the cardstock wraps around the bottom, but the pic on page 5 seems to show that there'll be no cardstock underneath. And, how well does this hold up with large, multi-level builds?
How's the reception been in other forums and with other terrain developers?
Do you have some pics of large-scale builds that you've done using all the different methods you're advocating? They'd be cool to see.
Thanks for sharing this as you progress. I apologize if I sound too much like I'm all negative. I just want to share the negatives now, so you can think about it all and make informed decisions that you think are best, before unleashing stuff on the world. 
|
) ...